What Does Your Workplace Teach You to Do? A Systemic Perspective

When people enter a workplace, we tend to think about what they bring with them.

Their personality. Their qualifications. Their experience. Their work ethic. Their strengths and weaknesses.

When someone performs well, we often attribute it to these individual qualities. And when someone struggles, we may be equally quick to look within the person for an explanation.

But workplaces do not simply receive people.

They also shape them.

Over time, every workplace teaches people something about how they need to behave in order to function within it.

Every Workplace Has Written and Unwritten Rules

Most organisations have formal policies, procedures, values and expectations.

But employees also learn another set of rules.

These are rarely written down.

They learn whether disagreement is genuinely welcomed or merely tolerated. They learn whether mistakes can be acknowledged openly or whether mistakes need to be hidden. They learn whether taking initiative is rewarded or whether it is safer to wait for permission.

They also learn who can challenge whom, which conversations can happen openly and which ones happen only after the meeting.

Nobody necessarily explains these rules.

People discover them through experience.

People Pay Attention to What Happens Around Them

Imagine a new employee entering an organisation.

Initially, they may be enthusiastic. They contribute ideas, ask questions and volunteer for responsibilities.

Then they begin observing.

Someone challenges a decision in a meeting and is subsequently labelled difficult.

Another employee makes an honest mistake and continues hearing about it months later.

Someone takes initiative without first consulting a manager and is criticised for overstepping.

Gradually, the new employee learns.

Not because someone formally instructed them to change, but because they have been watching what happens to people around them.

This is one of the ways systems communicate.

What gets rewarded teaches. What gets punished teaches. What gets ignored also teaches.

Adaptation Can Look Like Personality

After several years in the organisation, the once outspoken employee may have become quiet.

Someone looking at them now might say:

“They're just not very assertive.”

But perhaps they were assertive when they arrived.

The employee who constantly seeks approval may be described as lacking confidence.

But perhaps they previously made decisions independently and learned that independent decisions carried too much risk in this particular environment.

The person who no longer offers ideas may be labelled disengaged.

But perhaps they have repeatedly experienced their contributions being dismissed.

What we eventually describe as a characteristic of the individual may sometimes be, at least partly, an adaptation to the system.

Leaders Are Also Shaped by Systems

This process does not only affect employees.

Managers and leaders are also operating within systems.

A manager may appear controlling because they work in an organisation where every mistake made by their team ultimately lands on their desk.

A leader may avoid difficult decisions because previous attempts to introduce change were punished.

A manager may become obsessed with targets because the system above them communicates that numbers matter more than how those numbers are achieved.

This does not remove their responsibility for how they lead.

But it reminds us that leaders are not operating outside the system.

They are participants within it.

Culture Is More Than What Appears on the Wall

Organisations often describe their culture through words such as:

Integrity. Innovation. Collaboration. Excellence. Respect.

These values can be meaningful.

But organisational culture cannot be understood only by reading the values displayed in reception or on a website.

Culture is also found in people's everyday experiences.

What happens when someone disagrees with a senior person?

What happens when an employee admits a mistake?

What happens when someone says, “I don't know”?

What happens when someone asks for help?

What happens when an employee challenges a practice that everyone knows is not working?

The answers to those questions may tell us more about the culture than the words displayed on the wall.

Culture is also what people discover they need to do to survive, belong and succeed within a system.

When Several People Develop the Same Problem

Individual accountability remains important.

Sometimes an employee is simply not performing adequately. Sometimes someone behaves unprofessionally. Sometimes additional training, supervision or performance management is appropriate.

A systemic perspective does not require us to abandon individual responsibility.

But it does encourage us to notice repetition.

If one employee struggles, we may reasonably examine the individual situation.

If several employees struggle in remarkably similar ways, something else becomes worth examining.

If different people repeatedly leave the same manager, perhaps the question should extend beyond the employees.

If enthusiastic recruits repeatedly become disengaged after joining the same department, perhaps motivation is not the only issue.

If people across an organisation are reluctant to speak openly despite leadership repeatedly encouraging openness, perhaps the question is not simply why employees lack courage.

At some point, repetition becomes information about the system.

The System May Be Producing What It Complains About

This is one of the more uncomfortable possibilities for organisations.

Sometimes a system unintentionally contributes to the very behaviour it wants to eliminate.

An organisation complains that employees do not take initiative, while requiring multiple layers of approval for relatively small decisions.

Leadership says it wants honesty, but reacts defensively when difficult feedback is offered.

Managers say they want employees to take responsibility, but intervene whenever someone approaches a task differently from how they would have done it.

The organisation then sees the resulting caution, silence or dependence and concludes that employees need to change.

But what if the environment is helping to produce that behaviour?

That question does not assign blame.

It creates an opportunity for reflection.

Psychological Safety Is Learned Through Experience

People do not decide whether an environment is safe simply because leadership tells them that it is.

They learn through experience.

If I admit that I made a mistake, what happens next?

If I disagree respectfully, what happens to our relationship?

If I ask a question that exposes something we would rather not discuss, what happens to me afterwards?

If I say that I am struggling, is that information used to support me or eventually held against me?

Over time, people collect answers to these questions.

And then they adjust their behaviour accordingly.

This is why telling employees to “speak up” is not always enough.

The system has to demonstrate what happens when they actually do.

A Different Question for Leaders

Leadership conversations often focus on the behaviour leaders want from employees.

How do we make people more accountable?

How do we encourage innovation?

How do we improve engagement?

How do we get employees to take ownership?

These are useful questions.

But there is another question worth placing alongside them:

“What kind of behaviour does the system I lead make possible?”

If you want initiative, what happens when someone takes initiative and gets something wrong?

If you want honesty, what happens when someone tells you something you do not want to hear?

If you want accountability, are people given enough authority to actually take responsibility?

If you want collaboration, what does the organisation reward — collective success or individual competition?

Leadership is not only about asking people to behave differently.

Sometimes it is about creating conditions in which different behaviour becomes possible.

What Has Your Workplace Taught You?

It can also be useful to turn the question towards ourselves.

Think about the environments in which you have worked.

What have they taught you?

To speak up?

To remain quiet?

To take initiative?

To wait for permission?

To admit mistakes?

To hide them?

To collaborate?

To protect yourself?

To ask for help?

To make sure you never appear uncertain?

Some of these lessons may have helped you function successfully within a particular environment.

But adaptations can travel with us.

Sometimes we leave an organisation while continuing to behave according to rules that belonged to the previous system.

Becoming aware of what we learned gives us an opportunity to decide what we want to carry forward.

Look Beyond the Individual

People matter.

Personality matters.

Competence matters.

Individual choices matter.

But people do not work in a vacuum.

They respond to relationships, leadership, power, expectations, consequences and the unwritten rules around them.

So when behaviour in an organisation becomes difficult to understand, perhaps we should resist the temptation to look only at the individual.

Sometimes the more revealing question is:

What has this environment been teaching people to do?

Because one of the clearest ways to understand a system is to look at the behaviour people have learned inside it.

Through a Systemic Lens is an ongoing series of reflections by Lobone Raditladi exploring the relationships, patterns and systems that shape our lives.

See the system. Understand the pattern. Create meaningful change.

Leave A Comment

All fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required